Welcome to Finance and Fury.

  1. This episode – be looking at one of the simplest ways to potentially generate alpha and outperform the broader market
  2. It’s been a decade since financial markets have become increasingly centrally-planned by central banks and with this – disconnected from fundamentals
    1. Hence – traditional analysis of shares based around their fundamentals may not provide outperformance – however – I think it is still important to understand which are good companies to buy into
    2. Looking at fundamentals and understanding these and their implications in the broader sense can be hard – takes many years to learn
    3. But what if there is an even simpler strategy to beat the market and generate alpha?
    4. That is where there is one interesting strategy from some quants – released an article called “Can quants make money by tracking the Fed books?”
      1. Runs through trading alongside the Fed’s balance sheet – as this seems to be the dominant price setter in markets
      2. Been talking about this emergence in a few episodes recently – but interesting that some quant traders are now implementing this
    5. Looking at the influence the Fed has had on share prices –
      1. Monetary policy has the ability to influence asset prices – a lot of evidence that low interest rates and accompanying expansionary in monetary supply creates rallies in assets with risk – monetary contractions can create market retreats  
        1. been more obvious since the GFC – market reactions appear to have become increasingly aligned and dependent on central bank actions – especially that of the Fed
        2. This is in part due to policies such as QE – as well as forward guidance from CBs – with statements like to the effect of supporting markets by any means necessary – increasing speculation and the dive head first into those assets that will be supported
      2. In 2008 – the total assets on the Fed balance sheet have expanded from $2.3tn to about $7tn today – this is a growth rate of over 200%
        1. Over the same time – S&P 500 rose from 900 to about 3,300 -growth of about 270%
      3. Over the shorter term – this year specifically – From March the Fed was sitting on about $4.7tn and this has grown to the previously mentioned $7tn figure – a growth of about 48%
        1. the S&P 500 over the same period has returned about 42%
      4. There is definitely a correlation here – but there is likely a causal relationship as well due to the flow of money into the markets that comes with the Feds balance sheet expanding – injecting liquidity as they would call it
    6. But how predictable are asset returns based on prior Fed action and can this be used as a tool to outperform the market?
      1. Technically – Fed policies have to be transparent – hence they can be market-moving – if traders are paying attention – so there is likely a first mover advantage here –
    7. Looking at what the quants wrote as their trading strategy – or what they are looking at – simply following the Fed
      1. They first go through the observation of the correlated movements between markets and the balance sheet of the Fed – have many charts showing the relationship between the growth of the Fed balance sheet and a variety of risk assets
      2. They note that the sheer scale of unconventional monetary policy does seem to have also made asset returns more predictable, and performance appears increasingly contingent on central bank actions. This provides a potential opportunity for investors.
      3. Fed has committed to maintain its asset purchase programmes “at least at the current pace to sustain smooth market functioning”, and with ultra-low rates expected to at least until 2023, according to the Fed, it is clear these unconventional monetary policies are going to remain a key driver of markets for some time.
    8. The quants note introduces a simple tactical alpha strategy that uses the growth of the Fed balance sheet to measure the degree to which monetary expansion is supporting risk-asset rallies
      1. The strategy – implemented in the context of the classic long-only equity/cash decision (buying and selling shares) – “provides supportive evidence of market predictability and the potential to utilize measures of unconventional monetary policies in designing systematic strategies”
      2. This means that to outperform the market – you can follow the growth of the feds balance sheet – as they note based around their simulations – doing so “generates a sizable outperformance with a reasonable success rate”
      3. Important to point out that this model is illustrative – provides a framework to extend to analogous risk -on/-off
    9. They did run some observations on if the relationship between the Fed causal beyond what is correlated –
      1. presented the correlation of weekly growth in total Fed balance sheet assets with lagged and subsequent returns of the S&P 500 index – what they found:
        1. “The negative correlation between lagged stock market performance and current growth in Fed assets (left-hand chart) means that stock market declines increase the likelihood of Fed action in the form of balance sheet expansion. On the other hand, the positive correlation between subsequent stock market performance and current Fed asset growth means that Fed balance sheet expansion leads to positive stock market performance. The impact of Fed asset growth on equity markets lasts, on average, for the subsequent four weeks.”
        2. “Consistent with economic priors, balance sheet expansion leads to stronger positive market returns, and our analysis shows that this lasts for up to four weeks, following the policy change, with a peak observed at three weeks. On the other hand, and contrary to expectations, Fed balance sheet contractions are also followed, on average, by market rebounds, although the strength of these correlations were much weaker in the initial three weeks, with a stronger bounce on the four-week mark.”
      2. So there appears to be a small announcement effect initially – but then the market reaction appears gradual – peaking at the 4 week mark
        1. Could be for a number of reasons – information delay – through to it taking 4 weeks for the liquidity to hit equities – through the purchases being in the Fixed Interest markets and for those on the secondary market to turn around and use the funds to buy shares – or it could be the impact on the lowering costs of capital for companies pushing up the valuations – whatever the reason – there is a lag  
      3. Can these observations be traded – this isn’t advice – but general in nature – based around what the evidence shows
        1. The Quants design of investment strategy considers the distinctive lead-lag correlations between Fed expansion and Fed contraction – so they designed a weekly tactical alpha strategy based on Fed asset growth that aims to boost investment returns by selectively overweighting riskier assets during Fed monetary expansion regimes. To that end, the quants used weekly Fed balance sheet data over the period of 2009 and Sep. 2020 – a period of intensive use of unconventional monetary policy tools
        2. The strategy consists of using a classic equity-cash allocation with the goal of generating excess returns by systematically tilting towards risk opportunistically following expansionary monetary policy
        3. In the illustration – they used a long-only portfolio with a strategic allocation of 75/25 between equity and cash – their evidence showed that the impact of Fed asset growth lasts on average for four weeks with the lead-lag correlation to cumulative S&P returns peaking at around the fourth week. The input to the strategy is the weekly growth rate in the Fed total assets, and the strategy seeks to allocate more to equities (from safe asset holdings) during periods of monetary easing as reflected in the growth in Fed assets.
        4. the performance of this simple tactical tilting strategy shows that they would have been able to provide annualized excess returns of 2.5%
      4. So based around these models – it appears to work – can it continue working?
        1. If it is implemented correctly – and assuming that the causal relationship is due to the spill over effects from programs like QE or corporate bond purchases
        2. But there is no denying that the Feds movements do now move markets –
      5. the quant strategy implemented in the context of a long-only equity/cash portfolio provides some evidence of the potential to utilize the Fed as a partner in generating returns – if they are going to expand the money supply and this is going to flow into risk assets – like shares – why not follow?
        1. The Quant simulation generates a sizable outperformance with a reasonable success rate
        2. What else should we expect in the financial world where trillions of additional dollars from the expands of the Fed balance sheet have the ability to flow into shares once they are loosed into financial markets
      6. This being said – the Fed balance sheet-tracking strategy probably shouldn’t be the sole investment strategy that people use –
      7. Important to remember goals and look at your own risk tolerances and the point of investing
      8. But it could be useful as an overlay – given the massive numbers of other factors that affect markets and their performances – the Fed balance sheet strategy could also be blended with other trading decisions

Thank you for listening to today’s episode. If you want to get in contact you can do so here: http://financeandfury.com.au/contact/

 

The future of the share market: How central bank intervention will be a dominant factor going forward.

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Investing in the equity or debt markets in the world with greater levels of Central bank interventions – The rebounds of the market – seems to be responding to the Fed and the US Treasury Last week – the ASX recorded its biggest one-day...

Fractal property investments: dipping your toe into the property market

Episode 19 Fractal property investments: dipping your toe into the property market It’s no secret that property is expensive in Australia – it can be pretty disheartening for those trying to get into the property market especially if you’re trying to buy your first...

What are the best ways to save for a home deposit?

Welcome to Finance and Fury – For this week’s episode we are answering a question from listener David – surrounding some options to save for a home deposit “The conventional wisdom is to save for, say, a home deposit in a bank account with as high as possible interest...

How to achieve your new year financial goals through turning them into daily habits.

Welcome to the Finance and Fury and the new year, 2021. Hope the start to the year has been good for you all – as in this episode we will be looking at how to work on your financial goals through the year through turning these into daily habits Last episode - Stared...

Why would Central bankers want to crash economies, create political division and start wars?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Furious Friday Edition. Today – continue talking about wars – the banker's wars – this time on us and financial markets– Gone through how bankers fund wars, central banks carry out monetary policy that leads to Hot wars Start a...

Starting an online business or franchise

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday edition John’s Question: I thought a useful topic could be about pros and cons off starting a business and starting your own business vs buying a franchise system etc. and using a business to achieve financial...

Goals and Risk profiles, and Philosophy and Strategy workbook guides

Welcome to Finance and Fury Today we will be going through the workbook itself How to put the goals and risk profiles together How to work out the investment philosophy and strategy How to put together the investment plan and checklist Three downloads - Found on the...

(Intro Series) The wrap up party

Intro - Episode 6 The wrap up party Hey guys! Welcome to the wrap up party for this little intro series Well done if you’ve made it to this point listening. I know a lot of it could have come across pretty confusing …and don’t worry I was quite confused myself by this...

Is Bitcoin the future of money?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Furious Friday edition Been talking about monetary system – today dive into Crypto currency Crypto currency – means nothing - has to do with individual coins/tokens/whatever –   Preface – Don’t have as deep an understanding on the...

Is it a good time to invest? How to overcome investment uncertainty and start investing

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Things seem to be calming down – markets have recovered somewhat – the US election volatility has been minimal – may see some short-term movements this week This episode – How to overcome investment uncertainty and start investing! The...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This