Episode 17

ETFs and the greater economy – their impact on financial crises and bubbles bursting

Though banks bear much of the blame for previous financial crises, ordinary investors play a more central role than most people realise…

…through greed, and fear.

Ironically, it is likely to occur through a vehicle which has been created with just that in mind – exchange-traded funds, or ETFs

Listed funds are passive by nature, designed to track the performance of an index of stocks, bonds, currencies or commodities, rather than to pick and choose among individual companies.

The ETFs are very popular;

  1. The simplicity and low costs
  2. But they could be a time bomb for global markets.
    • Australia – Only listed in Australia in 2009, when it was cheap to buy shares (after the GFC)
  3. The popularity of ETFs has soared in the past decade.
    • Passively managed have nearly doubled = 40 per cent of Funds under management (in America)
    • Vanguard alone owns a position greater than 5 per cent in 491 of the stocks on the S&P 500, adding up to nearly 7 per cent of the index’s total market cap.
    • Japan, where the central bank owns big stakes in ETFs, passive investors hold over half of all share market assets.

 

It’s easy to see why such funds have thrived. ETFs, invested in indices that are theoretically diversified, have consistently outperformed active managers. There are more fund managers than shares because there are a limited number of shares.

Their simplicity is appealing to lay investors, who can focus on broad asset-allocation strategies rather than guessing at individual winners and losers.

Hidden risks

  1. ETFs, however, are riskier than many investors appreciate.
  2. With cap-weighted indices – funds have no choice but to load up on shares that are already overweight (and often pricey) and neglect those already underweight.
    • As prices rise, investors may become overexposed to a few large shares
    • That’s the opposite of “buy low, sell high.”
  3. ASX 300 ETF – $12.5 Bn – One fund is 1% of Aus market cap
  4. ASX 300 – Market cap of $1.5 trillion
    • Commonwealth Bank of Australia
    • BHP Billiton
    • Westpac Banking Corp.
    • CSL Ltd.
    • Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd.
    • National Australia Bank Ltd.
    • Wesfarmers Ltd.
    • Woolworths Group Ltd.
    • Macquarie Group Ltd.
    • Rio Tinto
  5. The top 10 holdings represent 42.8% of the total ETF.

 

ETFs can replicate indices in complicated ways.

  1. Rather than purchasing all the assets consistent with index weights, some funds use a sub-set, thus exposing investors to tracking error.
  2. ETFs must be fully invested and therefore hold minimal cash, which could limit flexibility in a downturn. The rules governing indices can be changed, sometimes arbitrarily.
  3. ETFs – by their design and their sheer size – ETFs encourage concentration in a few liquid, large-cap stocks, creating homogenous and momentum-following markets.
  4. To have low costs: ETFs to emphasise scale, further exacerbating concentration to the top heavy in the ASX

 

Risk of bubbles

  1. Markets become susceptible to flows from a few, large, passive products.
  2. Artificial factors, such as inclusion or exclusion from an index, forces buying and selling; this can lead to misallocations of capital. In the current equity cycle, for instance, over-weighted, liquid, large-cap stocks have benefited disproportionately from forced buying. This increases the risk of bubbles, as in 2000 with the dot-com crash.
  3. ETFs may even distort valuations outright.
    • They don’t analyse prices, meaning that they don’t contribute to price discovery.
    • They weaken corporate activism, as passive owners have little interest in corporate governance.
  4. ETFs increase volatility and shrink liquidity.
    • Passive funds exhibit significantly higher intraday trades and daily volatility, driven by arbitrage activity between ETFs and the underlying stocks.
    • With ETFs increasingly important as the marginal buyers and sellers of securities, this may increase volatility in periods of instability.

 

From passive to panic

  1. Index funds lock up a large percentage of shares that can only be traded on changes in market capitalisation or other index metrics.
    • Number of shares available to trade may be a lot smaller than investors realise. Especially when dealing with small-cap shares, liquidity will be lower on these assets
  2. If a crisis does arise, this is likely to exacerbate the downturn.
    • ETFs will have to sell quickly what they’ve disproportionately bought;
    • Passive indexers may become panic sellers.
      • But they may have trouble finding anyone willing to purchase the holdings they’re trying to liquidate.
    • Example: Imagine that an investor in an ETF with, say, a 10 per cent stake is forced to sell a large part its holding in a single day, such as an industry fund
      • If there are no ready buyers for such a large holding, causing the ETF to fall to a price below the value of the assets it owns.
      • This price impact may be exaggerated, as ETF activity intensifies both upswings and downswings.
      • Crashes, when they happen, may be bigger.

 

Take advantage

  1. How resilient you will be when conditions change.
  2. Untested structures have revealed hidden weaknesses which have threatened wealth and financial stability. There’s no reason to think next time will be any different.
  3. But: You can buy ETFs when they crash
    • If they crash, they will crash harder then most active managed funds

Summary

  1. Indexes are great, but not without risk
  2. Get some index, but make sure it is diversified
  3. Look at smaller caps, but LICs not ETFs in small cap

 

Thanks for listening!

Say What Wednesdays: What advice would you give your 21-year-old self?

Say What Wednesdays What advice would you give your 21-year-old self? Today’s question is from Declan, “What advice would you give your 21-year-old self?” To my 21-year-old self I would have the following advice: Life is a series of challenges, the more you solve the...

Why work your whole life, just to have nothing left over at the end?

Episode 8 Why work your whole life, just to have nothing left over? Pay yourself first! Keep your own money – why work for others, then have nothing left to show for it? You earn more over your lifetime with this strategy – you save more and get rich right? Regular...

Furious Fridays: How the Fair Go mobilises Australians

Welcome to Finance and Fury the Furious Friday edition. This is part 4 of the mini-series. Hope you all had a good Christmas. In the last episode, we talked about how the population is mobilised in a political spectrum. Today we talk about what the population is...

What is the First Home Loan Deposit Scheme? And how to use it?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday Edition  This week’s question comes from Adam Hey Louis, learning lots from your podcast its been good value. My question is now the coalition are remaining in power i want to take advantage of the proposed first...

Premiums are on the rise…but is Private Health Cover worth it?

Say 'What' Wednesday Premiums are on the rise...but is Private Health Cover worth it? Welcome to Finance & Fury, Say ‘What’ Wednesdays! where we answer your questions on finance and economy. Today’s question comes from Mike – ‘Hey mate, loving the show, what’s...

Why do Central Bank’s target 2-3% inflation and what are they trying to accomplish by having it in that range?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Say What Wednesday edition – Every week answering your questions – Hi Louis, thank you for the great content and the research you put in! I have another question you might be able to tackle: why do central banks target 2-3% inflation?...

Should you reduce debt or use surplus cash to build wealth? Negotiating with future-you

Say What Wednesday Should you reduce debt or use surplus cash to build wealth? Negotiating with future-you Welcome to Finance and Fury, “Say what Wednesday” Where we answer questions about the world of personal finance. This week, the question isn’t from a listener...

If you think that you’re a victim, you are really your own oppressor! Building wealth and demand in an Inclusive System

Furious Fridays If you think that you’re a victim, you are really your own oppressor! Building wealth and demand in an Inclusive System Welcome to Furious Fridays! Make sure you’re caught up with last week’s episode about the system and what it should provide System -...

How do you identify a scam, before ASIC or the regulators do it for you?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The say What Wednesday edition where we answer your questions, and sometimes questions from people from the gym – such as today Is this a scam – moneysmart have a page on this – which is good resource – give a quick summary of this – but...

How I buy shares – the horror stories and the happy endings, plus technical vs fundamental analysis

Say What Wednesdays How I buy shares - the horror stories and the happy endings, plus Technical vs Fundamental Analysis Welcome to Say what Wednesday Today's question is from Emma. She says, “I'm new to the podcast so not sure if you have covered this in the past. I...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This