Furious Friday

Is cheaper better, or do you get what you pay for?

Welcome to Finance & Fury’s ‘Furious Friday’!

Today’s misconception – Is cheaper better, or do you get what you pay for?

Met with a client this week for an initial appointment – He had been reading ‘The Barefoot Investor’

  • I haven’t read it, but he had a summary of the tips in the book.
  • His biggest take away were on the cost of things – basically, lower cost is the best option.
  • But is it? You pay for costs for a reason – to get something out of it!
    1. Super – Admin fees and Management fees
    2. Listed Investment Companies (LICs) – Management fees

Very true that when looking at ‘like for like’ products – cheapest is generally the better option

  1. When comparing the exact same: for example, buying a car – If ‘Car A’ and ‘Car B’ are the exact same, you go for the lower costs
  2. Close substitutes: If things are really similar ‘Car A’ and ‘Car B’ (Mazda and Hyundai) – Might go for a personal preference
  3. But how do you compare things like investments or superfunds?
    • Not all things are created equal
    • Comparing solely on costs can be a trap!

Not all things (like super) are ‘like for like’

  1. Admin fees
    • Host Plus – $78
    • Sunsuper – $78 + 0.1%
    • Australian Super – $78
  2. Investment options, returns and net costs: Returns – MERs – taxes = Net Returns
    • Income returns taxed at 15% on average

 

HostPlus

HostPlus

Sunsuper

Australian Super

Balanced Default

(1.45%)

Index Balanced

(0.06%)

Balanced

(0.9%)

Balanced

(0.75%)

2017

13.2%

10.3%

12%

12.44%

2016

5%

2.2%

8.9%

4.54%

2015

11%

10.8%

7.3%

10.86%

2014

13.6%

14.4%

7.6%

13.88%

2013

16.3%

18.7%

18.6%

15.63%

Cumulative returns

  • Host plus
    1. Balanced Default – 74.31%
    2. Index Balanced – 69.60%
  • Sunsuper – 67.01%
  • Australian Super – 71.59%

You get what you pay for here – because they are all managed and invested in similar ways

  • These options, however, might not be the best for all

My funds

  1. My super is with another platform that allows me to make the investments, so I can choose from 400+ other managed funds, direct shares, LICs etc.
  2. They do charge more though, so if you are going for multimanaged you will underperform, but if you go for other managers you will make up the difference.
  3. Needs to be non-index investments to make up the difference
    • Active funds
    • If you are higher growth, non-index, that increase in values more than income returns
    • My fund pays me franking credits
    • For me the costs are worth it to access the investments and franking credits

My main investment options:

 

OC Dynamic (1.72%)

Ausbil Microcap

(1.21%)

Magellan

(1.48%)

Platinum

(1.48%)

2017

29.80%

22.5%

14.23%

25.16%

2016

0.16%

2.68%

3.71%

4.65%

2015

27.60%

51.16%

15.27%

9.58%

2014

10.79%

9.16%

14.55%

7.79%

2013

25.6%

33.87%

48.69%

47.22%

Cumulative returns

  1. Average – 148.15%
  2. Not ‘like for like’ – More high growth than the industry funds.
    • But costs more – $175 flat + 0.3% of balance
    • MER – 1.4%

LICs vs ETFs

  1. LICs -Companies
    • Control Dividends
    • Make active investment decisions
  2. ETFs – Trusts (similar to managed funds)
    • Generally passive
    • Dividends, FCs – flow through to the investor

 

 

AFI (0.14%)

VAS

(0.14%)

WAM

(1% + 20% performance fee)

WAX

(1% + 20% performance fee)

1 year

8.6%

10.2%

15.5%

16.2%

3 years

3.2%

6.08%

14.9%

15.6%

5 years

6.1%

8.79%

15.9%

18.5%

10 years

5.00%

5.2%*

13.9%

n/a

*Accum index return – VAS hasn’t been around for that long but is the ASX index

Dividend payments

  • WAM – 6.6%
  • WAX – 6.4%
  • AFI – 3.96%

The take away

  1. If you know you’re comparing ‘like for like’ – Lower cost is best
  2. But you shouldn’t base all decisions around the costs only
    1. If you are comparing two large cap funds that do the exact same thing
    2. Or two super funds doing the exact same thing
    3. Go for lower costs
  3. Some things are worth the extra cost!

Is it a good time to invest? How to overcome investment uncertainty and start investing

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Things seem to be calming down – markets have recovered somewhat – the US election volatility has been minimal – may see some short-term movements this week This episode – How to overcome investment uncertainty and start investing! The...

How to avoid getting further into debt and get spending habits back in line

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Credit cards and pay day lenders are on the rise, as some of those out of work are becoming strapped for cash. Today, we look at this further but also look at some alternative strategies to avoid the debt traps. We’ll also look at how to...

We’re back

Start here We're back! We're back! Sorry to keep you waiting for quite some time, but our absence hasn’t been wasted. As you can probably tell the podcast looks a little different, but don’t worry, you’re not lost. To help avoid any further confusion this is a quick...

Furious Fridays: The Holocaust, famine in the Ukraine, and how we just keep repeating the same mistakes, Rick and Morty style

Furious Fridays The Holocaust, famine in the Ukraine, and how we just keep repeating the same mistakes, Rick and Morty style Welcome to Finance and Fury, Furious Friday Have a think about how much you know about history? Are you familiar with the big events, like WW1...

What creates a lack of resilience in financial markets and how a loss of resilience makes them prone for a collapse?

Welcome to Finance and Fury,  For the past few Monday episodes been talking about complexity theory and markets – check out Last two eps – went through phase transition, feedback loops and how markets become fragile and some signs this is happening Most recent...

Is Gross Output (GO) going to replace Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and are there any problems with this?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday edition. This week the question comes from Todd. “Hi Louis, I just saw Steve Forbes talking about how Gross Output (GO) is going to replace Gross Domestic Product (GDP) as a measure of how well the economy is going?...

Furious Fridays: What happens if the EU collapses?

Furious Friday What happens if the EU collapses? Welcome to Finance & Fury, the Furious Friday edition. For the past few weeks we’ve been talking about the EU and this week we’ll finish up by looking at the flow on effects of the EU breaking up. There’s no way to...

Say What Wednesdays: What’s an Education Fund and what are the tax benefits?

Say What Wednesdays What's an Education Fund and what are the tax benefits? Welcome to Say What Wednesday! This week the question comes from Sean, "You spoke about Education Funds in a recent episode, I’m just wondering if you can explain this further?" In this...

Furious Fridays: The Death of Stalin

Furious Fridays The Death of Stalin Last episode we ended with Lenin’s death. The roll out of Communism was well underway and it was time for new leadership. One his last policies before he died in 1924 was the New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1922… A mixed economy put in...

Furious Friday: Could gender pay gap regulations hurt women more than help them?

Furious Friday Could gender pay gap regulations hurt women more than help them? Welcome to Finance & Fury, the Furious Friday edition. Today’s episode is all about the drive to equality. A recent proposal by the Labour Government is to force equality through...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This