Furious Friday

Is cheaper better, or do you get what you pay for?

Welcome to Finance & Fury’s ‘Furious Friday’!

Today’s misconception – Is cheaper better, or do you get what you pay for?

Met with a client this week for an initial appointment – He had been reading ‘The Barefoot Investor’

  • I haven’t read it, but he had a summary of the tips in the book.
  • His biggest take away were on the cost of things – basically, lower cost is the best option.
  • But is it? You pay for costs for a reason – to get something out of it!
    1. Super – Admin fees and Management fees
    2. Listed Investment Companies (LICs) – Management fees

Very true that when looking at ‘like for like’ products – cheapest is generally the better option

  1. When comparing the exact same: for example, buying a car – If ‘Car A’ and ‘Car B’ are the exact same, you go for the lower costs
  2. Close substitutes: If things are really similar ‘Car A’ and ‘Car B’ (Mazda and Hyundai) – Might go for a personal preference
  3. But how do you compare things like investments or superfunds?
    • Not all things are created equal
    • Comparing solely on costs can be a trap!

Not all things (like super) are ‘like for like’

  1. Admin fees
    • Host Plus – $78
    • Sunsuper – $78 + 0.1%
    • Australian Super – $78
  2. Investment options, returns and net costs: Returns – MERs – taxes = Net Returns
    • Income returns taxed at 15% on average

 

HostPlus

HostPlus

Sunsuper

Australian Super

Balanced Default

(1.45%)

Index Balanced

(0.06%)

Balanced

(0.9%)

Balanced

(0.75%)

2017

13.2%

10.3%

12%

12.44%

2016

5%

2.2%

8.9%

4.54%

2015

11%

10.8%

7.3%

10.86%

2014

13.6%

14.4%

7.6%

13.88%

2013

16.3%

18.7%

18.6%

15.63%

Cumulative returns

  • Host plus
    1. Balanced Default – 74.31%
    2. Index Balanced – 69.60%
  • Sunsuper – 67.01%
  • Australian Super – 71.59%

You get what you pay for here – because they are all managed and invested in similar ways

  • These options, however, might not be the best for all

My funds

  1. My super is with another platform that allows me to make the investments, so I can choose from 400+ other managed funds, direct shares, LICs etc.
  2. They do charge more though, so if you are going for multimanaged you will underperform, but if you go for other managers you will make up the difference.
  3. Needs to be non-index investments to make up the difference
    • Active funds
    • If you are higher growth, non-index, that increase in values more than income returns
    • My fund pays me franking credits
    • For me the costs are worth it to access the investments and franking credits

My main investment options:

 

OC Dynamic (1.72%)

Ausbil Microcap

(1.21%)

Magellan

(1.48%)

Platinum

(1.48%)

2017

29.80%

22.5%

14.23%

25.16%

2016

0.16%

2.68%

3.71%

4.65%

2015

27.60%

51.16%

15.27%

9.58%

2014

10.79%

9.16%

14.55%

7.79%

2013

25.6%

33.87%

48.69%

47.22%

Cumulative returns

  1. Average – 148.15%
  2. Not ‘like for like’ – More high growth than the industry funds.
    • But costs more – $175 flat + 0.3% of balance
    • MER – 1.4%

LICs vs ETFs

  1. LICs -Companies
    • Control Dividends
    • Make active investment decisions
  2. ETFs – Trusts (similar to managed funds)
    • Generally passive
    • Dividends, FCs – flow through to the investor

 

 

AFI (0.14%)

VAS

(0.14%)

WAM

(1% + 20% performance fee)

WAX

(1% + 20% performance fee)

1 year

8.6%

10.2%

15.5%

16.2%

3 years

3.2%

6.08%

14.9%

15.6%

5 years

6.1%

8.79%

15.9%

18.5%

10 years

5.00%

5.2%*

13.9%

n/a

*Accum index return – VAS hasn’t been around for that long but is the ASX index

Dividend payments

  • WAM – 6.6%
  • WAX – 6.4%
  • AFI – 3.96%

The take away

  1. If you know you’re comparing ‘like for like’ – Lower cost is best
  2. But you shouldn’t base all decisions around the costs only
    1. If you are comparing two large cap funds that do the exact same thing
    2. Or two super funds doing the exact same thing
    3. Go for lower costs
  3. Some things are worth the extra cost!

Premiums are on the rise…but is Private Health Cover worth it?

Say 'What' Wednesday Premiums are on the rise...but is Private Health Cover worth it? Welcome to Finance & Fury, Say ‘What’ Wednesdays! where we answer your questions on finance and economy. Today’s question comes from Mike – ‘Hey mate, loving the show, what’s...

Are our Lithium companies at risk from South America?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday Edition Today’s question from Zed “I recently noticed that Australia seems to be opening lots of lithium mines as the demand for Electric Vehicles rises and we turn away from oil. Is Australia at risk of their...

Say What Wednesday: Makin’ coin flippin’ houses

Welcome to Finance & Fury’s Say What Wednesday Today’s question is from Lucas, “Hey guess, just wondering if you think that flipping houses is a good strategy? Can you really make a living flipping houses?” Good question! Flipping houses has become very popular...

Furious Friday: Are we destroying our own economy?

Welcome Finance and Fury the Furious Friday edition, and welcome to part 2 of talking about the risks and the future of our economy In the last episode, we covered the future of our economy In this episode, we will explore economic subversion and internal reliance...

Say What Wednesday: Is this the solution for pollution?

Welcome to Finance & Fury, the ‘Say What Wednesday’ edition. I recently received a great email from Nick, on a fantastic topic. So, I’ll read most of the email as background to today’s discussion;  “Hey Louis, I’ve recently be thinking about an issue that I think...

The skinny on spare change investment apps and building wealth when you’re earning $25,000 or less a year.

Say What Wednesday The skinny on spare change investment apps and building wealth when you’re earning $25,000 or less a year. Welcome to Say What Wednesdays – Where we answer your personal finance questions each week. Two questions this week from Chris: No 1 what are...

How much do you really know about cash and how it works?

Episode 26 How much do you really know about cash and how it works? In this episode we discuss Cash. We will run through what type of asset it is, how the currency system works, and how it can be manipulated! We also discuss: The good old days of the Gold Standard...

Should you reduce debt or use surplus cash to build wealth? Negotiating with future-you

Say What Wednesday Should you reduce debt or use surplus cash to build wealth? Negotiating with future-you Welcome to Finance and Fury, “Say what Wednesday” Where we answer questions about the world of personal finance. This week, the question isn’t from a listener...

Say What Wednesday: The relationship between shares and property in Australia

Say What Wednesday The relationship between shares and property in Australia Welcome to Finance and Fury’s ‘Say What Wednesday’. Today’s question is from John. John asks, “What is the relationship (if any) between shares and property in Australia? Should we expect the...

How does the share market’s behaviour changes with investor theory?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Furious Friday edition Today We will go through how the share market changes with economic theory, particularly the theory of Milton Friedman in regards to shareholder value and certain volatility The share market behaviour changes as...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This