Say What Wednesday

The relationship between shares and property in Australia

Welcome to Finance and Fury’s ‘Say What Wednesday’. Today’s question is from John.

John asks, “What is the relationship (if any) between shares and property in Australia? Should we expect the broader share market to react to falling property prices?”

Great question!

Correlation – a mutual relationship or connection between two or more things

  1. That is, what are the price movements doing in relationship with one another?
    • Does property price rise and fall with shares? Or the other way around? Are they consistently moving in the same direction or in opposite directions?
  2. Correlation doesn’t mean causation!!

 

Just because things are related it doesn’t mean that they are caused by one another, for example Lisa Simpson’s rock that repels tigers.

Correlation between asset classes

The correlation between the asset classes and that factors that play into this.

Study showed that shifts in stock and property markets can lead to the emergence of an unstable linear relationship between these markets.

  • This supports that there is some causality between equity and property markets however it showed that the equity market had an influence on the property market, but not the other way around.
  • “The results also indicate that non‐linear causality tests show a strong unidirectional relationship from the stock market to the real estate market.”

asset class correlation

  1. Ranges between 0.2 to 0.8 – changes over time depending on market factors
    • Property companies – highly correlated
    • Wider market – not as correlated
    • However, the Big 4 banks make up 20-25% of the ASX and their major revenue comes from lending market – less loans = less money
  2. Is it Causal?
    • Globally not so much
    • But in Australia, yes – if property goes down, ASX may drop as well if the banks drop
    • If banks lose 30% of their value = ASX drops 7.5% = Cause a panic sale in the market
  3. Do people see property as an alternative?
    • Yes and no – people see more risk in shares
    • All comes back to confidence – Share market returns look more homogenous (moving as one)
  4. Confidence in the economy – Good for one, and good for the other
    • When people see shares go up = Gives confidence that things are good in the economy
    • This can lead to increased in house prices as people then go out and buy more property
    • Also – when companies do well, people are employed and earn more
    • When incomes and individual wealth increases through employment people can afford loans

Conclusion

  • There is no clear correlation but having both property as well as shares can help get a full diversified portfolio.

Say What Wednesday: Getting tied up with Investment Bonds

Say What Wednesdays Getting tied up with Investment Bonds Welcome to Finance and Fury’s ‘Say What Wednesday’ where we answer your questions on personal finance. Today’s question today comes from William who asked us to do an episode on Investment Bonds. Investment...

Why I finally bought another property and is this a good financial decision?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. This episode is about a bit of personal story “Why I finally bought another property and if is this a good financial decision?” So – if the episode title didn’t give this away - I have recently bought a property – well - technically not...

Furious Fridays: The Holocaust, famine in the Ukraine, and how we just keep repeating the same mistakes, Rick and Morty style

Furious Fridays The Holocaust, famine in the Ukraine, and how we just keep repeating the same mistakes, Rick and Morty style Welcome to Finance and Fury, Furious Friday Have a think about how much you know about history? Are you familiar with the big events, like WW1...

Would a one world currency actually work?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Furious Friday edition.  In this episode we will look at the concept of a one world currency and if one single currency could actually work for the world? There has been an increased level of discussion around this topic over the past...

Furious Fridays: The Devil giveth and the Devil taketh away

Furious Friday The Devil giveth and the Devil taketh away Welcome to Finance and Fury! If you haven’t listened to last Friday’s episode go check it out, it’s a prelude to this episode. Today we are going to discuss the founder of Communism – Karl Marx, along with his...

Do value shares perform better than growth shares when inflation levels are high?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. This episode – want to continue looking at theory versus reality – Focus on the theory of Value versus Growth investing in an inflationary world – and which one does better Looked at if inflation will return – but if it does - maybe Value...

Crony capitalism and Modern Monetary Theory in action!

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Furious Friday edition. Today we’re looking at Modern Monetary Theory in action. The first stage, how this is going to be practically done, involves the merging of the central banks and Government Treasury. We’ll also look at the...

Is the economy back to the 1970s?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. In this episode, we will be looking at the economy of the 1970s – looking at the share market correction that occurred and what contributed to this – the aim of this episode is to see if will we experience the same sort of market...

Buying Property inside an SMSF: Tips and traps, what works and what doesn’t

Say What Wednesday Buying Property inside an SMSF: Tips and traps, what works and what doesn't Welcome to Finance and Fury, 'Say What Wednesdays' where each week we answer your questions. This week's question is from Sandeep: “Hi, Can you please talk about how to...

Taking a deeper look at the property price models of the RBA

Welcome to Finance and Fury. This episode we’ll take a deeper look into the RBA property market models and how different inputs affect prices. Potential models that give the ability forecast future growth of the market based around assumptions – from a study by the...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This