Episode 9

The Great Debate! Managed Funds vs ETFs vs LICs…what they are, how they work and what’s best to invest in.

The debate!

(it’s not time for a math debate, there will be numbers)

Please do listen to our episode “Pay yourself” first

The choices are: Managed Funds, ETFs, LICs

  • What they are and what they do
  • Features and what works best
  • Who will win?

Disclaimer – Full disclosure, I own all three types. Bought shares first, Managed funds about 6 years ago (tech super longer), ETFs and LICs in past 3 years.

Introducing the contenders:

  1. Managed Fund – more managed funds than shares on ASX. 31 December 2017, the managed funds industry had $3,389.6b funds under management (FUM), not FUN, FUM, fun for managers for fees. But some are worth it.
    • Structure – Unit trust
    • Price– Net tangible assets. All shares in UT are worth $1,000,000. units 1,000,000 = $1 Units
    • Underlying investment
  1. ETF
    • Structured as managed funds, but on the ASX – Unit trusts – Income and FC flow through based on holdings. Dividend may not be FF
    • Price – Supply demand, but – Net tangible assets. All shares are worth $1,000,000. Shares 1,000,000 = $1NTA
    • Underlying investment
  1. LIC
    • Structured as company – Income determined by board, FC usually paid (due to tax)
    • Price – Net tangible assets. All shares are worth $1,000,000. Shares 1,000,000 = $1NTA
    • Underlying investment – Mostly shares – Different segments – small cap, styles

Company V Trust – one has discretion, one is a flow through – value is the same, vs other company

What are they? – Features

  1. How are they traded and when?
    • End of day – MFs
    • Intermarket – LICs, ETFs
  2. Diversification
    • Index – Lots of shares, top heavy
    • Active – 30-150 shares, select sectors/styles
    • Asset classes – Managed funds allow greater access to alt. investments
  1. Costs
    • MERs – percentage-based cost 1% of $100 = $1
      • passive MFs same as ETFs 0.18%, Active 0.8-1.4% p.a. – LICs/MFs
    • Platform costs – Admin fees %, plus flat, sometimes built into platforms (AMP)
    • Transaction costs – per $1,000, each year
      • Buy sell – 0.2% = $2, 1 year = $24
      • Brokerage – $20 = 2%, 1 year = $240

 

Investment styles

  1. Active
  2. Passive
  3. Target investments
  4. Performance/Volatility

Winners:

  • Managed funds – transaction costs, investment styles, diversification
  • ETFs – MERs, off platform, index diversification
  • LIC – Investment style

Losers

  • Managed funds – MERs, platform costs,
  • ETFs – brokerage
  • LIC – brokerage

In the end:

  1. How much will you invest?
  2. For how long?
  3. What is the end goal?
  4. How risky are you? – Costs and volatility – reduce your performance
  5. How active do you want to be or hands off?

Summary

I like all three – this is what I do…

  1. Managed funds – use for smaller monthly investment – as $100 minimums per fund.
  2. LICs – invest into when dividends come in
  3. ETFs – same as LICs – invest when dividends come in.

How to analyse share markets by treating them as a complex system

Welcome to Finance and Fury Series on Share markets as complex systems – a different way of thinking about them – This episode, discuss some basics of shares and introduce complexity theory – Nonlinear, Emergence, Spontaneous order, Adaption, Feedback loops Shares -...

The story of Dave Portnoy and a warning to any new traders about overleveraging.

Welcome to Finance and Fury. This episode is about the story of Dave Portnoy and a warning to any new traders of overleveraging – or even using leverage if you are relatively inexperienced There are Millions of new investors are getting into the market- which is great...

Why I finally bought another property and is this a good financial decision?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. This episode is about a bit of personal story “Why I finally bought another property and if is this a good financial decision?” So – if the episode title didn’t give this away - I have recently bought a property – well - technically not...

The Cash Bill – stabilising the financial system for negative interest rates, Bail Ins and more, all at your expense

Welcome to Finance and Fury Last Monday's ep – Cash Restrictions Bill – Went through black economy and outline of regulations Today – Go further into implications of this – along with other considerations such as bail-ins and negative rates why bill needed – not for...

(Intro Series) What does your retirement look like, and why?

Intro - Episode 5 What does your retirement look like, and why? What do you normally think about before you go anywhere? Anyone who has ever left the house before has probably had to think about something before taking a step out the front door. Anyone who hasn’t,...

Should I switch my investments from High Growth to Conservative and why store gold personally instead of a vault?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday Edition Back to answering individual questions - Two questions this week – follow up to recent episodes on gold and economy First from Mario – just a quick one - I listened to a recent podcast you made about gold and...

Furious Fridays: Busting the myth that our big 4 banks are “Too Big to Fail” (Part 1 of 2)

Furious Friday Busting the myth that our big 4 banks are "Too Big to Fail" (Part 1 of 2) Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Furious Friday edition! Today’s misunderstanding is about the “Too big to fail” myth. I want to tell you a story. It’s probably a relatively...

Say What Wednesdays: Financial Advice – The process, the costs, and if seeking advice is for you

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday Episode, where every we answer questions from you guys! This week’s question comes from Nelson, “Hi mate, Love the podcast. Admittedly don't agree with some of your more conservative political opinions but that aside...

9 reasons your loan may have been rejected

Episode 38 9 reasons your loan may have been rejected Welcome to Finance & Fury. Today we’re talking about 9 reasons you may have your home loan application declined. We have Jayden Vecchio this episode running through the 9 reasons. As a result of the recent...

Furious Friday: Could social security be the greatest Ponzi scheme ever?

Furious Friday Could social security be the greatest Ponzi scheme ever? Welcome to Finance and Fury, Furious Friday! I saw an ad this week for a movie called ’Wizard of Lies’ – Bernie Madoff movie – 2008. He was a stockbroker, investment adviser and financier who made...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This