Episode 9

The Great Debate! Managed Funds vs ETFs vs LICs…what they are, how they work and what’s best to invest in.

The debate!

(it’s not time for a math debate, there will be numbers)

Please do listen to our episode “Pay yourself” first

The choices are: Managed Funds, ETFs, LICs

  • What they are and what they do
  • Features and what works best
  • Who will win?

Disclaimer – Full disclosure, I own all three types. Bought shares first, Managed funds about 6 years ago (tech super longer), ETFs and LICs in past 3 years.

Introducing the contenders:

  1. Managed Fund – more managed funds than shares on ASX. 31 December 2017, the managed funds industry had $3,389.6b funds under management (FUM), not FUN, FUM, fun for managers for fees. But some are worth it.
    • Structure – Unit trust
    • Price– Net tangible assets. All shares in UT are worth $1,000,000. units 1,000,000 = $1 Units
    • Underlying investment
  1. ETF
    • Structured as managed funds, but on the ASX – Unit trusts – Income and FC flow through based on holdings. Dividend may not be FF
    • Price – Supply demand, but – Net tangible assets. All shares are worth $1,000,000. Shares 1,000,000 = $1NTA
    • Underlying investment
  1. LIC
    • Structured as company – Income determined by board, FC usually paid (due to tax)
    • Price – Net tangible assets. All shares are worth $1,000,000. Shares 1,000,000 = $1NTA
    • Underlying investment – Mostly shares – Different segments – small cap, styles

Company V Trust – one has discretion, one is a flow through – value is the same, vs other company

What are they? – Features

  1. How are they traded and when?
    • End of day – MFs
    • Intermarket – LICs, ETFs
  2. Diversification
    • Index – Lots of shares, top heavy
    • Active – 30-150 shares, select sectors/styles
    • Asset classes – Managed funds allow greater access to alt. investments
  1. Costs
    • MERs – percentage-based cost 1% of $100 = $1
      • passive MFs same as ETFs 0.18%, Active 0.8-1.4% p.a. – LICs/MFs
    • Platform costs – Admin fees %, plus flat, sometimes built into platforms (AMP)
    • Transaction costs – per $1,000, each year
      • Buy sell – 0.2% = $2, 1 year = $24
      • Brokerage – $20 = 2%, 1 year = $240

 

Investment styles

  1. Active
  2. Passive
  3. Target investments
  4. Performance/Volatility

Winners:

  • Managed funds – transaction costs, investment styles, diversification
  • ETFs – MERs, off platform, index diversification
  • LIC – Investment style

Losers

  • Managed funds – MERs, platform costs,
  • ETFs – brokerage
  • LIC – brokerage

In the end:

  1. How much will you invest?
  2. For how long?
  3. What is the end goal?
  4. How risky are you? – Costs and volatility – reduce your performance
  5. How active do you want to be or hands off?

Summary

I like all three – this is what I do…

  1. Managed funds – use for smaller monthly investment – as $100 minimums per fund.
  2. LICs – invest into when dividends come in
  3. ETFs – same as LICs – invest when dividends come in.

Investing in infrastructure as part of a wealth accumulation strategy.

Welcome to Finance and Fury.  This episode will looking at infrastructure as an asset class, to see if it can help to provide some diversification for portfolios and decent moving forward. Infrastructure – physical assets that provide services that are essential for...

How do you know that the share markets are likely to be in for a collapse?

Welcome to Finance and Fury Last week - The lead up of markets in relation to complexity theory – phase transitions and feedback loops in markets https://financeandfury.com.au/how-to-analyse-share-markets-by-treating-them-as-a-complex-system/ Today – look at the...

Building a strategy to fit your goals

Welcome to Finance and Fury Today we are continuing from last week, and going through strategies to fit your goals. Some bad news… The workbook will be released next week because there are a few pieces missing, as it doesn’t achieve what I wanted it to. So as a DIY...

A quick announcement about episodes for the rest of the year

Hi and welcome to Finance and Fury. Just a quick announcement today. Only going to be doing Finance and Fury Monday episodes for the rest of the year. There is a lot going on with work and life in general and I just need to cut back a bit on the episodes. Had to make...

Has the first domino in the next banking crisis fallen?

Welcome to Finance and Fury Snuck this episode in ahead of time – only reading about news yesterday – need to do some further digging – but is it Time to sell shares in anticipation of a crash? Today – run through some news that you might not have seen – financial...

The battles between Central Banks and Governments during the great depression, and the plot of a Military Coup

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Furious Friday Edition Last ep – lead up to the market crash of 1929 - and how thanks to central bank leveraging once removed – the market crashed Today – want to run through the internal political wars that were created – similar...

Stop procrastinating and start investing!

Welcome to Finance & Fury, today we’re going to be looking at what stops people from investing. The common reasons I see; Fear and misconceptions Not knowing what to invest in Not knowing how to invest Not knowing the benefit Not having enough to invest The last...

Say What Wednesday: The perfect investment mix

Say What Wednesdays The perfect investment mix Today’s Say What Wednesday question is from Linus. Linus asks, ‘I was just wondering what you think the ideal weighting of Australian (ASX200) ETFs, similar international ETFs and Bonds is in an investment portfolio? Love...

What are the governments gas-fired recovery plans and can this help with economic growth?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. The Say What Wednesday edition. This week we’re continuing the Question from Phuong - Part of the question from last week that wasn’t covered. “I heard about the Government’s plan to build some gas station? do you think this is green...

Is it time to jump into or get out of the tech bandwagon?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. A lot of people may be feeling regret right now - regret for not holding technology shares like Afterpay – it is up around 850% from the low in March Was not buying tech shares a bad decision? And is there potential from here? Look at this...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This