Welcome to Finance and Fury

Today we are discussing the concentration risk

Last week – how the modern banking system acts like dominos failing– Due to their liabilities and obligations to one another

  1. this week – look at the other side of the balance sheet – Which is the Equity Holders – Shareholders – who owns the shares of banks
  2. Also – the concentration risk that just a handful of companies have in the overall size/weight of the Aus Share Market.
  3. Plus – Look at two events that every bank just did as this is a real-world example

 

Concentration in the index – Complex with lots of elements – break down major ones

Remember – Big 4 banks – including Macquarie = 5 of the top 8 companies on ASX by market cap

  • Australian bank shares – ownership and connectivity – beyond the derivative concentration
  • representing 23% of ASX300 – IMF report in 2012: big four controlled 88% of residential mortgages and 80% of deposits.
    • biggest six American banks held 30% of total deposits
  • not just banking: the big four own 53% of life insurance premiums, 57.3% of retail investment funds through bank-owned platforms –
    • Insurance and investment sides to banks also purchase shares on the ASX – of which they make up a large chunk
    • This can just further increase the concentration risk of markets – if an investment manager owns 5% of a share and sells, that moves the prices down – a lot – average daily volume is about 0.15% – both buys and sells –
  • Beyond banks owning their own shares directly – Subsidiaries – Investments,
    • Banks – through super funds, investment managers, insurance companies – either buy them through own subsidiary or another bank –
    • Super funds (investment managers) – Industry/index funds – hold shares on the ASX –
      • Example – Aus Super – Balanced fund has $100bn in it – 22% allocation – range of 10-45%
      • ASX market cap – $1.6-$2trn depending on the market cycle – $2trn now, but $1.8trn middle ground
    • What can easily lead to a downturn in the share market? What if you have $2.8tn across all super funds – plus $100bn inflow p.a. – and super investment managers decide to dump the ASX? –strategic ‘rebalancing’ or ‘profit-taking’
      • If the target is 25% to AS – a drop in exposure by 10% down from 35% – selling shares/index –
      • ASX $2trn – a sale of a super fund in Aus shares by 10%, sale of 14% of shares held on the ASX –
  • that is a lot of power to move a market – top 20 super funds have around $1.3trn of the super investments
    • also a lot of power in the property market – cover more in another episode
  • Names on the list – Broken up between Public Sector, Industry or Retail (banks) – Pretty equally split in % of top 20
    • Of the retail funds – about $420bn in 8 – Bank Subs or non-bank financial services
      • MLC Super (NAB), CFS Super (CBA), Retirement Wrap (BT), OnePath super – ANZ
      • AMP super – 2 funds, IOOF super, and Mercer (owned by USA insurance company – Marsh & McLennan)
    • Bank Major holdings – Blackrock entities – 3 of the top 10 for every bank but NAB – ‘Advisors, Management, UK’
      • Macquarie has about 7% of its shares
    • But this is who the owners are – banks use custodial holding companies – HSBC, JPM, CitiGroup – 40-55% between 3

 

Beyond just being investors in one another and Concentration through connectivity and custodial power –

Banks are Counterparty to each other – either a lender/borrower to one another – derivatives last week example of one side

  • But big 4 banks are highly interconnected – each other’s largest counterparties – nobody else is big enough
  • the connection is far from direct ownership of shares – but banks borrowing from each other, rather than owning large parts of each other – Balance sheet has assets and liabilities – Under lending laws – lenders get paid back before investors
    • If a bank borrows another money, and one bank goes out of business – banks get any money first – shareholders probably get $0 – when you look at the size of the loans to overall ‘equity’
  • Thankfully for them – the global markets and companies are just as easily reached as domestic ones – financial services can fall under free trade
    • Not so good for us – as when a banking crisis happens in USA – we get hit just as bad
  • Requiring each other – as there is so much money needed only one of the other big four can normally help
    • Banks fund costs through short term debt securities – why hold cash – when you can use it to lend at 3.5% and borrow at 1.5% interest – like funding your lifestyle on CC and investing the rest of the money – then trying to repay the debt using your investment earnings – doesn’t work unless you can consistently get over 22% p.a. returns on an investment to outpace the accumulation of debt – but if you got 22% investing, and card was 2% – who wouldn’t do that?
  • When there is a crash in the banking system – hard to fund expenses as nobody wants to lend to you – GFC –
    • Called liquidity crisis – but in reality, was an insolvency crisis – two different things – as banks don’t even have the assets to fund any ‘bank runs’
    • Further hastens the decline in share values due to cashflow losses – rule of business: cant meet expenses = bankrupt
  • If you look at a banks balance sheet – almost worthless – Shares themselves in Banks are insolvent in values –
    • DB had total assets of 1.541 trillion dollars and total liabilities of 1.469 trillion dollars – difference of $72bn is in shareholder equity
    • CBA – Total assets $975bn – liabilities at $907bn – What is lest is shareholder equity – 7% of assets
    • WBC – Total assets $880bn – liabilities at $815bn – $64.5bn left or 7.3% of assets
    • Most banks run on this margin – Hsbc – massive value of assets – $2.56 trillion total assets –
    • Remember – Loans to you are assets to banks – if you borrow = liability
  • Banks values come from the ability to make money – Price is What we will pay for shares
  • Bank shares – Total equity or market cap – or what shares are worth on market prices
    • CBA – $146.5bn – 7.4% – Shareholder Equity (book value) – $67bn – Banks assets minus liabilities
    • WBC – $99bn – 5%, ANZ – $80bn – 4%, NAB – $75bn – 4%, MQG – $42.7bn – 2%
    • But if they lose a small margin in assets = no equity left – Regulators aware – hence the recent issues of debt and equity

 

These are becoming heavily controlled – legislated – APRA forcing banks to increase their reserve capital – money against loans

  • This is done through issuing ‘Subordinated notes’ – this is part of the Bail-in regulations that are being put into place
    • Issue debt – they call it bonds – but notes with provisions of write off if APRA determines it is necessary
  • Reason for doing this? Banks liquidity – Issue equity – raise money from creating new shares and converting them
  • Balance sheet 101 – if someone buys your debt (i.e. you borrow money) – if your assets don’t go up to match it = negative
    • This is where the balance sheet of a bank best maximises its profits when it gets as close to 0% net assets reflect
    • But if they issue debt, they need equity to balance the books – this is where shares are issued to counteract
  • major Banks are doing both – creating new shares and selling them in chunks – to other banks/financial companies – issuing billions of $ in shares to the other – SIBs or SIFIs (terms in the big to fail eps – where to invest and where not to)
    • Issuing shares where the trading can be legislated – ban sales – easier to do than the unpopular approach of shutting the market down –
      • But newly created Common Equity Tier 1 capital to offset the increased liabilities – which are used as capital reserves – but dilutes the number of shares – unless profits grow by more, dividends suffer

 

Where value comes from? – Future cash flows and profits – Based on debts and leverage – Profit from both ends –

 

Investment firms buy bank shares – Or new corporate debt in banks if they are fixed interest managers –

  • Odd thing – Banks were told by APRA to raise $500m (approx.) in reserves – But they seem to be quadrupling
    • Debt in USD – by CBA, NAB -, $1.5bn – WBC – $2.25bn USD,
    • ANZ – strangely has in AUD floating – well issues new FPO shares and the buyers were themselves and JP Morgan
    • NAB – Just Citigroup Global Markets alone – 38m shares – $26.28 = $1bn to offset the notes

 

Probably going to be costly – Interest payments on this – dilution of profits for dividends to existing shareholders

The solution to holding more on the balance sheet as ‘capital reserves’ = fund it with debt that can be traded away in the future – Does this make sense?

  1. Remember – you are giving them $1,000 upfront – so if the notes go to $200, or are converted at that value, or not honoured – which is allowed if 5 days pass without the conversions occurring upon APRA notifying a bank –
  2. The complex connections don’t end there – a lot of these conversion laws are regulated in US laws – USD face values

 

At this stage, looks to be a similar lead up to pre-GFC –

  • Instead of MBS – debt products with mortgages as backing assets – Now with bail-ins you take investor money for debt, which can then be written off if APRA determines a bank may become non-viable
  • While you may not directly own these notes – A lot of the retail and industry Investment managers are the largest holders of banks – and also banknotes – through super or some index funds, you are indirectly invested in these
  • Ongoing protection racket – protection that is provided isn’t for the individual investors – if it works once, may as well give it another go

Lead into next episode – what are super funds doing with your money?

Holdings – https://www.marketscreener.com/COMMONWEALTH-BANK-OF-AUST-6492243/company/

 

Thanks for listening to today’s episode. If you want to get in contact you can do so here. 

Nailing Business Cashflow Forecasts, whether you’re established, looking to expand, you’re a start up or a business in trouble

Hi Guys and welcome to Finance and Fury’s ‘Say What Wednesday’ Episode. Today we’re joined again by Nick. Our question today comes from Justin who asks, “Our building company recently went through issues with its cashflow, so as directors we halved our wages to help…I...

The Central Banking Bubble and what happens to asset prices if central banks stop QE?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Furious Friday edition I often wonder – Why the Fed/Central banks continue with polices that create a massive misallocation or resources and are hurting the economy more than helping – well – what If they cant stop or a collapse might...

How much is the economy of regional Australia worth?

Say What Wednesdays How much is the economy of regional Australia worth? Australia's regional workers and their contribution to the economy: Welcome to this week’s ‘Say What Wednesday’ episode! Our question today comes from Anna …who was actually listening to our...

Say What Wednesday: What is the real danger behind Climate Change?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday edition. Today we are going to cover off on Climate Change. This may be a bit weird. But, the majority of proposed solutions are political/economic. Firstly, the taxation on CO2 emissions. What is this going to do to...

How is traditional asset diversification is getting harder in a world with increasingly correlated asset classes?

Welcome to Finance and Fury Traditional asset class allocation Diversification getting harder Diversification in a world where most asset classes are becoming correlated Diversification: what it is and isn’t Diversification across asset classes is one of the most...

All that glitters: How precious metals, like Gold and Silver work as alternative investments, and how they fit into an investment portfolio.

Episode 34 All that glitters: How precious metals, like Gold and Silver, work as alternative investments, and how they fit into an investment portfolio. Welcome to Finance & Fury. Today we’ll be running through some alternative assets – precious metals, like Gold...

Say What Wednesday: The ups and downs of Bitcoin – currency, investment opportunity, both… or neither?

Say What Wednesday The ups and downs of Bitcoin - currency, investment opportunity, both... or neither? Today’s question comes from Richie, who asks, “Have you been following the Bitcoin ETF at all? If so, are you able to do an episode on this and if it is worth...

Are we in a property bubble and if so, why?

Welcome to Finance and Fury,  Are we in a property bubble? There is no question that the Australian property market has become significantly overpriced – but is it a bubble and due for a significant downturn? – For this – only talking about capital cities – most of...

One of the best places to invest in 2019, is to invest in yourself

Welcome to Finance and Fury! Today’s episode we continue our miniseries which looks at the best places to invest in 2019… Turns out, one of the best places to invest in 2019 might actually be in, Yourself. Today’s episode is the first building block for the next two...

Say ‘What’ Wednesdays: Is it time to jump ship? Should you sell your bank shares?

Say 'What' Wednesday Is it time to jump ship? Should you sell your bank shares? Today’s question comes from Jake. He asks “should I sell my bank shares, given the recent fall out from the royal banking commission?” IMPORTANT: This episode comes with a general advice...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This