Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Say What Wednesday edition, every week answering your questions. This week we answer Stephen’s question:

“Hi Louis,

I saw an article about purchasing a home inside of a family trust for asset protection. I’m just wondering if you have seen this done before and if you think it is a good idea?”

Thanks for the question – this episode – look at purchasing your own personal place of residence inside of a family trust – and what the pros and cons of this strategy are – because in short – it is definitely possible to do, but if not done correctly – it can put you in a worse position

Quick note – I’m not a legal expert – if you are considering this – important to get expert advice on this – this episode will just be discussing the general gist of the concept – and potential ways to avoid some of the major cons

Firstly – What is a family trust – or discretionary trust –

  1. family trust refers to a discretionary trust set up to hold a family’s assets – set up as a different owner of assets than someone individually owning an asset –
    1. On a family trust – you have the trustee which is the person that owns or controls the asset
      1. Corporate or individual
    2. the beneficiaries of the trust are the person(s) for whom the asset (e.g. a property) is owned –
    3. Have other entities like the appointer – power to add and remove the trustees –
  2. A family discretionary trust is probably the most common type of trust if someone was wanting to invest in a property
    1. The trustee can use their discretion to distribute the trust’s income and assets to the beneficiaries, allowing the family members to take advantage of tax benefits
    2. It also provides asset protection – if you are a director of the corporate trustee – technically you don’t own the assets inside of the trust
  3. So you can own lifestyle assets like you own home inside of a family trust –
    1. Quick note -this doesn’t work for a SMSF – it is inside the superannuation environment and to hold any asset here – it needs to meet the sole purpose test –
    2. This is that any assets are for your retirement solely – so buying a property to live in inside of this structure breaches this and you cant live in it

 

However – there are some Issues and considerations that need to be made for owning a property inside of a family trust –

owning property in a trust for asset protection purposes will usually mean that you lose its tax-free capital gains status as well as creating land tax implications

  1. Not normally an issue for investment properties – as CGT is payable anyway as it is an investment given it gets an income
    1. However – losing this on a PPR could be a major deal – buying a home for $600k and then a decade later selling it for $1m may result in $200k of additional assessable income being taxed at marginal tax rates (getting the 50% CGT discount) – may result in around $94k of tax payable at the highest MTR
  2. Looking at the CGT exemptions – Can a family trust claim a CGT exemption for the principal place of residence?
    1. Technically – the answer is no – as the trust is not a natural person it fails to meet the PPR CGT exemptions – so normally if someone wanted to claim a CGT exemption for a principal place – this would fail and CGT would be payable upon the sale of the property –
    2. Even the ATO on their website have the following: Generally speaking, the main residence exemption does not apply to the sale of assets held by trusts, as a transfer of a CGT asset to or from a trust will create a CGT event. Therefore, transferring the title of the property from a trust to personal names will also create a CGT event
    3. ATO rules – Generally, if you are an individual (not a company or trust) you can ignore a capital gain or capital loss from a CGT event that happens to your ownership interest in a dwelling that is your main residence (also referred to as ‘your home’). To get the full exemption from CGT:
      1. the dwelling must have been your home for the whole period you owned it
      2. you must not have used the dwelling to produce assessable income
  • any land on which the dwelling is situated must be two hectares or less, and
  1. you must not be an excluded foreign resident at the time the CGT event occurs.
  2. However – in the income tax assessment act – Paragraph 160 ZZQ12(a) requires that a dwelling be owned by a natural person
  3. And a family company or family trust is not a natural person for these purposes.
  • However, where a beneficiary of a trust is absolutely entitled as against the trustee to the dwelling, an exemption may be available to the beneficiary if the dwelling is the principal residence of the beneficiary.
  1. So this means there is a way around this – but it can be complex and costly to achieve
  2. A Main Residence Trust can be created – it is like a discretionary form of trust, under which an individual is given a limited form of interest sufficient to attract the CGT Main Residence Exemption – in other words – the beneficiaries of the trust who reside in the property are given absolute entitlement
    1. To do this – in the trust deed – has to set out an equitable right of residence that is granted from the trust to a beneficiary
      1. But this needs to be sufficient to give an interest in the land that will attract the main residence exemption. Hence the term absolute entitlement
      2. Therefore – If the property is sold in the future, the sale can be structured so that the CGT exemption can be applied.
    2. Does this then fail the asset protection – i.e. the whole point of owning a property in the trust? Why give absolute entitlement if it can be taken away –
      1. Well – as a discretionary form of trust – provided that the trust deed is appropriately worded – no beneficiary can be said to have any interest in the assets of that trust – whilst they may have an absolute entitlement on paper – this doesn’t mean they have any financial interest in the property – or claim to the assets value – so this means that if any of the persons who are simply beneficiaries suffer financial calamity or are sued personally – the trust assets will not be available to satisfy the debts of that beneficiary – so if you get sued then the property can’t be used as collateral
    3. There is another way around this – if the trust deed hasn’t been set out correctly – and if the trust already owns the individuals main residences – to get the CGT exemption – a long term lease may be needed
      1. Some people see this as a suitable option to formalise the living arrangements and ensure access to the main residence CGT exemption if a sale occurs in the future
      2. Under a long term lease arrangement, the tenant obtains an “ownership interest” in the residence
        1. Have to specify this as ownership interest is the term is used in the capital gains tax ‘main residence’ exemption legislation
  • Upon the sale of the property – the tenant (i.e. you) would be entitled to a surrender payment in return for the actual surrender of the tenancy
    1. This surrender payment would be assessable income in the hands of the tenant and provided that the arrangement has been properly structured and administered, would attract the main residence exemption.
    2. However – The value of the land upon sale would be reduced by the value of the long term lease
    3. So the total market value of the interests in the property would be divided between the land value and the lease value – and rent would be nominal so that the long term value of the lease to the tenant would be substantial enough to offset the assessable surrender payments – so no tax should be payable
  1. These forms of main residence Trusts and Long Term Leases can be difficult and complex to setup from a legal and tax perspective – may cost a few thousand dollars to set up and maintain each year
  1. The other issue is land tax – however – there are some ways around this – does vary state by state – so gain to get advice on this –
    1. But generally – If the land value inside of a trust is more than $350k in QLD, or in NSW it is a flat 1.6% of the land value inside of trusts – can get expensive
    2. So similar to the CGT exemptions – Trustees eligible for the principal place of residence exemption also include the beneficiaries who also reside in the property – QLD is pretty cut and dry
      1. Technically – The exemption is not available for land owned by a trustee of a discretionary trust, a unit trust scheme or a liquidator – However, concessionary tax treatment is available for land held by a trustee of a discretionary trust or a unit trust scheme which is occupied by a beneficiary as their principal place of residence – however the trustee needs to nominates that person as the principal place of residence beneficiary
      2. You have to nominate this with the government in each state however
    3. So as an example – if you have additional investments inside of the trust – and you list your children as beneficiaries for tax purposes – distributions
      1. If they move out – but are still beneficiaries – can run afoul of these rules
      2. Hence it may be better to set up a trust, call it the main residency trust – for the sole purpose of owning your PPR

So, in short – it is possible to overcome these two major downsides of ownership of property inside of a family trust – I have seen this done before – but there wasn’t much point to it

 Questions to consider –

  1. How badly do you need asset protection –
    1. The asset protection that most family trusts provide is for external litigators of issues – outside of family
    2. It doesn’t provide protection against divorces or in the family courts –
  2. Is the cost versus benefits worth it – the upfront and ongoing costs can be, well, costly
    1. Have to look at the pros and cons for this – over a 20 year period it may cost you $40-60k to maintain the trust structure depending on legal and accounting fees – this is just an estimate – may be much more
    2. But these funds may be better spent paying off the debts

Thank you for listening to today’s episode. If you want to get in contact you can do so here: http://financeandfury.com.au/contact/

Goals for the New Year

Welcome to Finance and Fury Welcome to the new year, depending on when you listen it may be new year’s eve or the new year  Hope you are in for a good night, or not recovering from one. Starting off with a question; looking back on the year, are you in a better...

How to avoid getting further into debt and get spending habits back in line

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Credit cards and pay day lenders are on the rise, as some of those out of work are becoming strapped for cash. Today, we look at this further but also look at some alternative strategies to avoid the debt traps. We’ll also look at how to...

Say What Wednesday: Why is it unlikely the world economy will move away from Oil?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Say What Wednesday edition, where we answer your questions. Today we have a question from Nick - Watching the Leonardo Di Caprio documentary about global warming, which touched on how the large oil corporations used bribes to corrupt...

Why the Australian Share index is so reliant on just 5 companies and the risks that this brings

Welcome to Finance and Fury Today we are discussing the concentration risk Last week – how the modern banking system acts like dominos failing– Due to their liabilities and obligations to one another this week – look at the other side of the balance sheet – Which is...

What allocation has the most consistent returns?

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Sorry for the sporadic episodes – flat out with EOFY - In this episode we look at different asset allocations and how they have performed over time in relation to their returns as well as their risk – with a final focus on their risk...

Private equity investments

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Looking at alternative to listed shares, with private equity. Globally, private equity has for many years been a niche area of the investment universe, dominated by institutional investors and very wealthy individuals. However, trends in...

How does the adaptability of humanity open the door to Global Economic control?

Welcome to Finance and Fury, The Furious Friday edition   Today we start discussing the SDGs in relation to The economy – few SDGs this relates to Go through each in detail in separate episodes – but this ep is an overview into how deep this goes. UN goals as...

Take control of your money – nobody else is going to do it for you

Episode 30 Take control of your money - nobody else is going to do it for you Welcome to Finance & Fury! On today’s episode we take look at the best ways to secure your financial future I’m going to share the rules I follow – And how to not be a victim It isn’t...

When to refinance and negotiate value

Welcome to Finance and Fury. Today we have Jayden with us, and we will be talking about negotiating with banks and refinancing. Refinancing: Pros and Cons and how to negotiate Bank Valuations Interest rates might go up or might go down.so this is all about asking, is...

Options for reversing the “big bang” deregulations and the economic reliance on central banks.

Welcome to Finance and Fury, the Furious Friday edition. Does the Government need to solve economic problems? Do central banks solve economic problems? If so – how? These are honest question that do need to be thought about - there seems to be this growing thought...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This